I need a real one

I was unable to get the scratches out of mine before I started taking the finish off. I will need new buttons because they are pitted and there is no use chroming pitting metal.
So whats the better option have these OEM rechromed and buy new buttons or buy some decent aftermarket ones that come with everything. They seem to run between 60-100. No sure what the quality is so let me know if you've had any dealings with the aftermarket stuff or door handle chromers.